opfinances.com Book a clarity review

Answers ยท Infinite Banking

Should I surrender paid up additions or take a policy loan?

It depends on whether the money is coming back. If you will repay within a few years, a policy loan usually costs less, because the additions stay in place and keep their death benefit. If you will never repay, surrendering paid up additions is often cleaner, because unpaid loan interest compounds against the policy for as long as you own it. A surrender is permanent, so ask to see both on paper first.

Surrendering additions sells a piece of the policy, and a loan borrows against it.

Both get cash out of a whole life policy, but they work in opposite ways. When you surrender paid up additions, the insurer cancels some of those small paid for blocks of coverage and sends you their cash value. You owe no interest and there is nothing to repay. The blocks are gone, though, along with their death benefit and every dividend they might have earned.

A policy loan leaves everything in place. The insurer lends you its own money and holds your cash value as collateral. The additions stay in the policy and stay in line for any dividends the insurer declares. In return you owe interest, and any balance you have not repaid comes out of the death benefit. Some insurers pay a different dividend on cash value you have borrowed against, so ask which kind yours is.

Quick note on who is talking. opfinances.com is a licensed insurance agency. We are not a financial advisor and not a fiduciary. This is general education, not advice about your situation.

A loan you repay in a few years usually costs less than giving up the additions.

Here is illustrative arithmetic, not a quote. Say you need 30,000 for a roof and the loan rate is 6 percent. Pay it back over three years and the interest comes to roughly 3,700. The additions never left the policy. They kept their death benefit the whole time.

Surrender 30,000 of additions instead and you pay no interest. But you cannot simply put the money back. To rebuild, you buy new additions through the rider at your older age, with a charge off the top, inside the rider's yearly limit and the modified endowment limit. For a short need you fully expect to repay, the loan is usually the cheaper way to do it.

A loan you never repay can cost more than the additions would have earned.

Loan interest you do not pay gets added to the balance, and then that interest is charged interest too. At 6 percent, 30,000 left alone for 20 years grows to about 96,000 owed. Suppose the cash value behind it grew at 4 percent over the same stretch. It would be worth about 66,000. The debt outran the collateral by roughly 30,000.

Those rates are made up for the example. Dividends are not guaranteed, and many loan rates float. What matters is the gap between the two. When the loan rate runs above what the cash value earns, an unpaid loan eats a little more of the policy each year. Let it run long enough and the policy can lapse with the loan still on it, which can produce a tax bill and no cash to pay it with.

So if the money is not coming back, say it is going to retirement income or a gift to a child, surrendering additions is often the cleaner move. You take the hit once and nothing compounds against you afterward.

Surrendering costs more death benefit than the cash you take.

Each addition carries more death benefit than cash value. So pulling 30,000 of cash value out by surrender can remove noticeably more than 30,000 of death benefit, and the younger you are, the wider that gap. A loan reduces what your family receives by the loan balance and nothing beyond it. If the death benefit is why the policy exists, that difference can matter more than the interest.

The tax treatment is different too. On a policy that is not a modified endowment contract, surrendered additions generally come out of what you paid in first, so tax usually starts only after you have taken back your premiums. A loan is generally not taxed while the policy stays in force. A surrender that cuts the death benefit in the early years can also trigger a fresh modified endowment test. Have a tax professional look at your policy before you do either.

Always borrowing is only right when your own numbers say so.

A lot of infinite banking material says to leave the additions alone and take a loan every time. Sometimes that is the right call. But the interest goes to the insurance company, and whether the loan wins depends on your loan rate, your dividend and whether you will really pay it back. Ask for an in force illustration run both ways, 20 years out, and read them side by side.

Any guaranteed cash value depends on the claims paying ability of the insurance company that issues the policy. Dividends are not guaranteed at all. We sell these policies, so hold us to every question below.

Before you decide

Questions worth asking.

What is the loan interest rate today, is it fixed or variable, and what is the highest it can go under the contract?

Does this insurer pay a different dividend on cash value I have borrowed against?

If I surrender this much in additions, exactly how much death benefit comes off, and can I ever buy it back?

Can you run an in force illustration both ways, one with a loan I never repay and one with the additions surrendered, out 20 years?

At what loan balance is this policy in danger of lapsing, and who warns me before it gets there?

Do you or the insurer earn more if I borrow than if I withdraw?

Related

Is it better to withdraw or borrow from a whole life policy?

For money you will repay within a few years, a loan usually costs less because the coverage stays whole. For money you will never repay, surrendering paid up additions often costs less over time, because unpaid loan interest keeps compounding against the policy.

Do I pay tax when I surrender paid up additions?

On a policy that is not a modified endowment contract, the money generally comes out of the premiums you paid first, so tax usually starts only once you have taken out more than you paid in. A tax professional should confirm that for your policy.

Can I put the money back after surrendering paid up additions?

Not directly. A surrender is permanent. You can only buy new additions through the rider, if it is still active, at your current age and price, inside the rider's limits and the modified endowment limit.

Does a policy loan reduce my dividends?

It depends on the insurer. Some pay the same dividend whether or not you have a loan. Others adjust the dividend on the borrowed portion up or down. Dividends are not guaranteed in either case.

Do I have to pay back a policy loan?

The contract does not require a payment schedule. But unpaid interest is added to the balance, the balance comes out of the death benefit, and a loan that grows past the cash value can lapse the policy and create a tax bill.

Where this fits.

This question sits inside a bigger one. Infinite Banking walks through the whole decision rather than this one piece of it.

On Point Finances is a licensed insurance agency, not a tax, legal, or investment adviser. This page is general education, not a recommendation, and reading it does not create a client relationship.

Start with a conversation