Answers ยท 401(k) Rollover
Is $200,000 enough to work with a financial advisor?
Usually yes, but not with everyone. Firms that charge a percentage of your balance commonly set a minimum at 250,000 or 500,000, so 200,000 gets turned away or handed to a call center. Hourly planners and flat fee planners have no minimum at all, and licensed insurance agencies are paid by the carrier rather than by you.
The number that gets you turned away is a business decision, not a verdict on you.
Firms that charge a percentage of what they manage usually charge around one percent a year. One percent of 200,000 is 2,000. A real planning relationship costs that firm more than 2,000 a year in staff time, meetings, compliance and software, so they set a floor. Commonly 250,000. Often 500,000.
That floor is arithmetic on their side of the desk. It says nothing about whether you saved enough, and it is not a comment on your retirement. It is a comment on their pricing.
People take it personally anyway. Being told you are not quite there yet, at 62, about money you spent thirty years building, lands like a grade. It is not one.
To be clear about who is talking. opfinances.com is a licensed insurance agency, not a financial advisor and not a fiduciary. This is general education, and the numbers below are illustrative arithmetic rather than a quote.
There are four ways to pay for help, and only one of them has a minimum.
A percentage of assets is the model most people have met. Roughly one percent a year, billed quarterly out of the account, whether or not anything changed that year. This is the model with the minimum.
Hourly is the second. Roughly 200 to 500 an hour in most of the country and higher in the Bay Area, with no minimum, because you are buying hours rather than handing over a balance.
A flat fee for a written plan is the third. Commonly a few thousand for the plan, sometimes with a smaller annual fee to keep it current. Again no minimum.
Commission is the fourth. The insurance company or the fund company pays the person when you buy something, so nothing leaves your pocket at the point of sale and there is no balance requirement. opfinances.com is paid this fourth way. You should know that before you read another line of this.
None of the four is clean. Each one pays the person across the table for a particular outcome, and the useful thing is knowing which outcome that is.
At 200,000 the percentage is not the small number it looks like.
One percent sounds like rounding. Run it forward and it stops sounding that way.
Take 200,000 and assume six percent a year for twenty years. The arithmetic gives roughly 641,000. Now assume five percent instead, which is the same six percent with a one percent fee taken out of it every year. That gives roughly 531,000. The gap is about 110,000.
Those are illustrative figures rather than a forecast, and nobody knows what any account will actually return. The point is not the ending balance. It is that a one percent fee on this money is not a two thousand dollar decision, and it is worth knowing exactly what the two thousand a year buys.
Set that against the same balance seen by an hourly planner. Six hours every other year averages a few hundred dollars. That is a very different shape of cost for work that may answer the same questions.
What you are being turned away from is usually investment management, not planning.
The percentage fee is priced for managing a portfolio. That is a genuine service. It is also not the thing that moves the number most at 200,000.
The decisions that move it are mostly not portfolio decisions. When you claim Social Security. Whether you take the pension as a lump sum or as income. Which account you draw from first so you stay under a tax bracket or a Medicare premium tier. What the survivor lives on when one of two Social Security checks stops.
Every one of those is answered in hours, once, and then reviewed. None of them requires anyone to hold your balance forever.
200,000 is comfortably enough for the help most people at 200,000 actually need. It may not be enough for the pricing model you happened to be quoted, which is a different sentence entirely.
Ask what the person is paid for before you take the meeting, including us.
If someone is paid a percentage of what they manage, then paying off your mortgage, delaying Social Security, or moving money into an income annuity all reduce what they earn. That does not make them dishonest. It means the incentive points one way and you should know which.
If someone is paid a commission, and that includes opfinances.com, they are paid when you buy a policy or a contract. Same rule, opposite direction. Ask what the payment is and what it is paid on. Anyone who will not answer that has told you something.
Where guarantees come into any of this, and they do with insurance contracts, a guarantee inside a contract depends on the claims paying ability of the issuing insurance company rather than on anything said in the meeting.
Ask for that answer in writing before anything is recommended, not afterwards on page eleven of the paperwork.
Most people asking this are really asking about one specific pot of money.
The 200,000 is rarely scattered across a dozen places. Usually it is one old employer plan from a job you left, sometimes with a smaller account beside it.
That narrows the question a lot. You are not looking for someone to run your life savings. You are facing one decision about one account: leave it where it is, roll it, convert part of it and pay the tax deliberately, or turn some of it into income you cannot outlive.
That decision gets made once, it is worth real money either way, and getting it right does not require handing anyone a percentage every year for life. It needs a few hours of clear thinking about your own tax picture, ideally with your own tax professional.
Before you decide
Questions worth asking.
How are you paid on this, in dollars, in the first year and in every year after that?
Do you have an account minimum, and if I am under it, what specifically changes about who I deal with and how often?
Am I buying a plan or the management of a portfolio, and can I buy the plan on its own without moving my money to you?
If your best advice were to pay off my mortgage, delay Social Security, or move money somewhere you do not manage, how would that change what you are paid?
Are you acting as a fiduciary on this specific recommendation, and will you put that in writing?
Added up over ten years, what does working with you cost me in dollars rather than in percent?
Related
What is the minimum amount to work with a financial advisor?
There is no industry minimum, because the minimum belongs to the pricing model rather than to the profession. Firms charging a percentage of assets commonly start at 250,000 or 500,000, and some at a million, because one percent of a smaller balance does not cover their cost of serving you. Hourly planners, flat fee planners and commission paid agents generally have no minimum at all.
Is a 1% advisory fee worth it?
It depends entirely on what the one percent buys. On 200,000 it is about 2,000 a year, and compounded over twenty years at a six percent assumption the drag is roughly 110,000 of ending balance. That is a fair price for real planning that stops one expensive mistake, and a poor price for a model portfolio you could hold yourself for a fraction of it. Ask what is included, in writing, and judge the fee against that rather than against the percentage.
Can I get financial help without paying a percentage of my savings?
Yes. Hourly planners charge for the time, flat fee planners charge for the written plan, and licensed insurance agencies are paid by the carrier when a contract is placed. There are free sources worth using first as well, including the Social Security Administration for your own benefit estimates and your plan provider for the actual fees and options inside your account.
Why did an advisor say I did not have enough to work with them?
Almost always because your balance sits under their firm's minimum, which is set by what their fee model needs to cover its costs. It is a pricing decision made long before you walked in and it is not a judgment on your savings. Firms with a different fee model will take the same balance without comment.
Should I pay for help at all if I only have 200,000?
A smaller balance is exactly where a single mistake hurts most, because there is less room to recover from it. Claiming Social Security at the wrong moment, or triggering an avoidable tax bill by moving an old plan the wrong way, can cost more than several years of any fee discussed here. What that argues for is buying advice by the hour or by the plan, not necessarily buying it as a percentage forever.
Where this fits.
This question sits inside a bigger one. 401(k) Rollover walks through the whole decision rather than this one piece of it.
On Point Finances is a licensed insurance agency, not a tax, legal, or investment adviser. This page is general education, not a recommendation, and reading it does not create a client relationship.